Creality vs Polymaker: 3d Printing Filaments Compared by Specs
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you compare creality vs polymaker 3d printing filament, you see two distinct approaches to material science. Both brands offer 1.75mm diameter filaments in 1kg spools. They share a focus on dimensional consistency for reliable extrusion. The main difference lies in their polymer chemistry. Creality provides PLA+ for general-purpose use. Polymaker offers ASA for high-strength outdoor applications. This choice depends entirely on your project requirements.
Key differences
| Aspect | Creality PLA+ 1.75mm White Filament, 1kg | Polymaker ASA 1.75mm Filament (1kg) |
|---|---|---|
| Material Type | PLA+ | ASA |
| Dimensional Accuracy | +/- 0.02mm | not listed |
| Heat Resistance | not listed | Up to 100˚C (212°F) |
| UV Resistance | not listed | Yes |
| Bed Temperature | not listed | 90˚C |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Creality PLA+ 1.75mm White Filament, 1kg if
- You need a filament for indoor prototypes or decorative items.
- You want verified dimensional accuracy for precise fits.
- You prefer a material that is easier to print with.
Choose Polymaker ASA 1.75mm Filament (1kg) if
- You are printing parts that will face direct sunlight.
- You require high impact resistance for functional tools.
- You need parts that withstand higher operating temperatures.
Verdict: Choose Creality PLA+ for standard, easy-to-print indoor projects where precision matters. Select Polymaker ASA when you need durable, weather-resistant parts for outdoor or mechanical use. Your decision rests on whether strength and UV stability outweigh ease of printing.
Creality vs Polymaker Filament Specs
Material Chemistry
You start with the polymer type. Creality offers PLA+, a modified polylactic acid that balances ease of printing with slightly improved strength over standard PLA. Polymaker provides ASA, an acrylonitrile styrene acrylate copolymer. ASA shares the rigidity of ABS but adds superior resistance to UV light and weather. This makes ASA far more suitable for outdoor parts. PLA+ is generally better for indoor prototypes or decorative items. The chemical difference dictates the entire printing environment and post-use durability for your specific project needs.
Dimensional Accuracy
Precision in filament diameter ensures consistent extrusion. Creality specifies a dimensional accuracy of +/- 0.02mm for its 1.75mm PLA+ filament. This tight tolerance helps prevent clogs and ensures uniform layer heights. Polymaker lists the 1.75mm diameter in its key specs but does not publish a specific tolerance value in the provided data. Without a stated tolerance, you cannot verify if Polymaker matches Creality’s precision claims. For users requiring guaranteed dimensional consistency, the explicit +/- 0.02mm specification from Creality offers a clear, measurable advantage.
Heat Resistance
Operating temperature matters for functional parts. Polymaker ASA withstands temperatures up to 100°C (212°F). This high heat deflection temperature allows prints to remain stable in warm environments, such as inside a car on a sunny day. Creality PLA+ has a lower heat resistance threshold, typical for polylactic acid derivatives. It may soften or deform at lower temperatures compared to ASA. If your prints will face heat, Polymaker’s material properties provide a significant performance edge. For cool indoor environments, this difference is less critical.
UV and Weather Resistance
Outdoor durability separates these two brands. Polymaker ASA is explicitly marketed as UV and weather resistant. It is less prone to environmental stress cracking, making it ideal for RC planes, car accessories, and exterior fixtures. Creality PLA+ lacks any mention of UV stability or weather resistance. PLA-based materials tend to degrade and become brittle when exposed to sunlight and moisture over time. If you plan to use your 3D prints outside, Polymaker is the only viable choice based on these specifications.
Net Weight
Both filaments come in identical packaging sizes. Creality provides a 1kg spool, which equals 2.2 pounds. Polymaker also provides a 1kg spool, weighing 2.2 pounds. The physical weight of the material is identical. There is no difference in the amount of filament you receive per purchase. This aspect is a complete tie. You get the same volume of printing material from both brands, assuming the spool dimensions allow for similar usage on your printer.
Which Filament Suits Your Next Project
Casual hobbyist printing decorative items
You should choose the Creality PLA+ filament for simple projects. It offers a consistent 1.75mm diameter with tight dimensional accuracy of plus or minus 0.02mm. This precision ensures smooth extrusion and reliable layer adhesion for standard models. The white color provides a clean finish for display pieces without requiring complex settings.
Maker needing durable outdoor parts
Select the Polymaker ASA filament for functional components exposed to the elements. It resists UV rays and weathering better than standard plastics. The material withstands temperatures up to 100 degrees Celsius, making it ideal for car accessories or RC planes. Its high impact resistance ensures your prints remain sturdy during daily use.
User printing mechanical brackets
Choose Polymaker ASA for rigid mechanical parts that require strength. The filament provides high toughness and reliable layer adhesion for functional prototypes. Its durability supports brackets and housings that bear stress. You get a professional-grade material designed for real-world applications where standard PLA might fail under pressure or heat.
The products compared
Creality PLA+ 1.75mm White Filament, 1kg
Best for: Standard FDM printing with white PLA+
- Material Type
- PLA+
- Filament Diameter
- 1.75mm
- Net Weight
- 1kg
- Dimensional Accuracy
- ±0.02mm
- Printing Technology
- FDM
- Dimensions
- 8.2 × 2.7 × 8.2 inches
View on Amazon: Creality PLA+ 1.75mm White Filament, 1kg Affiliate link
This Creality PLA+ filament comes in a 1kg spool with a 1.75mm diameter. The dimensional accuracy is rated at +/- 0.02mm, ensuring consistent layer height. It is designed for standard 3D printers and offers a white finish. You will get reliable prints for general prototyping or decorative items. The material type is PLA+, which typically provides slightly better strength and flexibility than standard PLA.
Pros
- PLA+ material offers improved durability over standard PLA
- Dimensional accuracy of +/- 0.02mm ensures consistent prints
- 1.75mm diameter fits most FDM 3D printers
- 1kg spool weight provides a standard volume for projects
Cons
- White color shows dust and fingerprints easily
- 1kg spool may require frequent reloading for large prints
- Limited to PLA+ material type without other options in this SKU
Good fit if
- You need reliable PLA+ filament for everyday prints
- You prefer white prints and do not mind maintenance
- You use standard 1.75mm diameter printers
Skip if
- You require high-temperature resistant materials like ABS
- You want to print in colors other than white
- You need larger spools to reduce print interruptions
Verdict: Creality PLA+ 1.75mm 1kg White delivers consistent accuracy for standard FDM printing. You should choose it if you prioritize dimensional precision and standard PLA+ performance for small to medium white prints.
Polymaker ASA 1.75mm Filament (1kg)
Best for: outdoor functional parts and prototypes
- Material Type
- ASA
- Filament Diameter
- 1.75mm
- Net Weight
- 1 kg
- Max Print Speed
- 50mm/s
- Size
- 1KG
- Application
- Functional Parts
View on Amazon: Polymaker ASA 1.75mm Filament (1kg) Affiliate link
This Polymaker ASA filament offers 1.75mm precision for functional outdoor prints. It withstands heat up to 100˚C and resists UV damage. The 1kg spool provides strong layer adhesion for durable parts. You get reliable performance for brackets or car accessories. It requires specific settings like a 90˚C bed temperature. This material combines ABS toughness with weather resistance for real-world use.
Pros
- UV and weather resistant for outdoor applications
- Withstands temperatures up to 100˚C
- High toughness and impact resistance
- Strong layer adhesion for functional parts
Cons
- Requires enclosed printer to prevent warping
- Nozzle temperature set at 250˚C
- Limited to 1kg spool size in this variant
Good fit if
- You need durable parts for outdoor use
- You require heat resistance up to 100˚C
- You want UV-resistant functional prototypes
Skip if
- You prefer easy printing without an enclosure
- You need lower temperature settings
- You want larger 2kg or 5kg spools
Verdict: Polymaker ASA Filament 1.75mm White is ideal for users needing durable, weather-resistant parts for outdoor applications. It fits those who can manage higher printing temperatures and require an enclosed printer for best results.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Creality PLA+ 1.75mm White Filament, 1kg | Polymaker ASA 1.75mm Filament (1kg) |
|---|---|---|
| Material Type | PLA+ | ASA |
| Filament Diameter | 1.75mm | 1.75mm |
| Net Weight | 1kg | 1 kg |
| Max Print Speed | not stated | 50mm/s |
| Dimensional Accuracy | ±0.02mm | not stated |
| Printing Technology | FDM | not stated |
| Compatible Material | PLA | ASA |
| Size | 1KG | 1KG |
| Application | not stated | Functional Parts |
| Dimensions | 8.2 × 2.7 × 8.2 inches | 7.87 × 7.87 × 2.36 inches |
| Weight | 2.2 pounds | 2.2 pounds |
| Color | White Pla+ | 115 - 1.75mm White (Hex Code: #Dbd7d6) |
| Model | Ender-PLA+ | PF01002 |
Frequently asked questions
Is Creality PLA+ stronger than standard PLA?
Yes, Creality PLA+ offers slightly improved strength over standard PLA. This modified polylactic acid balances ease of printing with better durability. You should choose it if you prioritize dimensional precision and standard PLA+ performance for small to medium white prints.
Can I use Polymaker ASA for outdoor projects?
Polymaker ASA is ideal for users needing durable, weather-resistant parts for outdoor applications. It provides the rigidity of ABS with better UV resistance. This filament fits those who can manage higher printing temperatures and require an enclosed printer for best results.
What is the spool size for these filaments?
Both the Creality PLA+ and Polymaker ASA come in 1kg spools. The Creality filament weighs 2.2 pounds with dimensions of 8.2 inches in height and length. The Polymaker ASA also weighs 2.2 pounds but features a taller, narrower spool profile.
Do these filaments require a specific printer type?
The Polymaker ASA requires an enclosed printer for best results due to its higher printing temperature needs. Creality PLA+ is suitable for standard FDM printing. Both use 1.75mm diameter wire, ensuring compatibility with most modern desktop 3D printers.
What colors are available for these brands?
Creality offers this PLA+ in White, specifically labeled as White PLA+. Polymaker provides its ASA in White, identified by the hex code #Dbd7d6. Both brands focus on this neutral tone for their featured filaments, ensuring clean results for various projects.
Which filament is better for functional prototypes?
You should choose the Polymaker ASA for functional prototypes. It is designed for outdoor functional parts and offers superior weather resistance. The ASA material provides the strength needed for durable components, whereas the Creality PLA+ is better for decorative or casual items.
How precise is the filament diameter?
The Creality PLA+ maintains a consistent 1.75mm diameter with tight dimensional accuracy. This precision ensures smooth extrusion and reliable layer adhesion. Polymaker also specifies a 1.75mm diameter for its ASA, ensuring reliable feeding into your printer’s extruder mechanism without jams.